Which of the following statements is most correct?
Click on the arrows to vote for the correct answer
A. B. C. D. E.Explanation
Increasing the corporate tax rate would lower the after-tax component cost of debt, thereby lowering the WACC, with all other things held constant.
Let's go through each statement one by one and evaluate its correctness:
A. All of these statements are true.
This statement suggests that all of the statements provided in the options are true. However, since we have multiple statements to evaluate, it is unlikely that all of them are true. Therefore, we can conclude that statement A is incorrect.
B. As a firm's debt ratio approaches 100 percent, the after-tax cost of debt, k(d)(1 - T) (after-tax component cost of debt, where T is the firm's marginal tax rate), will be at its lowest level.
This statement relates to the cost of debt as the firm's debt ratio approaches 100 percent. The cost of debt is calculated by multiplying the before-tax cost of debt (k(d)) with the after-tax factor (1 - T), where T represents the firm's marginal tax rate. The statement suggests that as the debt ratio increases towards 100 percent, the after-tax cost of debt reaches its lowest level.
In reality, this statement is incorrect. As the debt ratio approaches 100 percent, the risk associated with the firm's debt increases significantly. Lenders and investors become more concerned about the firm's ability to repay its debt obligations, leading to higher interest rates demanded by lenders. Consequently, the after-tax cost of debt actually increases as the debt ratio approaches 100 percent. Therefore, statement B is incorrect.
C. All of these statements are false.
This statement claims that all of the statements provided in the options are false. We have already identified that statement B is incorrect, so we can conclude that statement C is correct. However, it's important to evaluate the remaining statements to be thorough.
D. An increase in the corporate tax rate would lower the weighted average cost of capital for an average firm, other things held constant.
This statement suggests that an increase in the corporate tax rate would lower the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for an average firm, assuming all other factors remain constant. In reality, this statement is incorrect. An increase in the corporate tax rate would generally increase the after-tax cost of debt, as the firm would have to pay more in taxes on interest payments. Consequently, the WACC, which incorporates the cost of debt, equity, and other capital sources, would likely increase rather than decrease. Therefore, statement D is incorrect.
E. Depreciation-generated funds have a cost equal to the firm's lowest WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital), and hence they have no impact on the MCC (Marginal Cost of Capital) schedule.
This statement concerns the cost of funds generated through depreciation. It suggests that depreciation-generated funds have a cost equal to the firm's lowest WACC, and as a result, they have no impact on the Marginal Cost of Capital (MCC) schedule.
In reality, this statement is incorrect. Depreciation-generated funds do not have a cost equal to the firm's lowest WACC. Depreciation is a non-cash expense that reduces the firm's taxable income and, consequently, its tax liability. However, depreciation does not directly impact the cost of capital or the WACC. The cost of capital is determined by the required returns from various sources of capital, such as debt and equity. Therefore, statement E is incorrect.
To summarize, statement C is correct, and statements B, D, and E are incorrect.