Reviewing which of the following would BEST ensure that security controls are effective?
Click on the arrows to vote for the correct answer
A. B. C. D.C.
Reviewing security metrics provides senior management a snapshot view and trends of an organization's security posture.
Choice A is incorrect because reviewing risk assessment policies would not ensure that the controls are actually working.
Choice B is incorrect because reviewing returns on security investments provides business justifications in implementing controls, but does not measure effectiveness of the control itself.
Choice D is incorrect because reviewing user access rights is a joint responsibility of the data custodian and the data owner, and does not measure control effectiveness.
Out of the four options provided, security metrics would be the best way to ensure that security controls are effective. Here's why:
A. Risk assessment policies: Risk assessment policies are important for identifying potential risks to an organization's security. However, while risk assessment is a crucial step in developing effective security controls, it is not enough to ensure that those controls are actually working as intended. Risk assessments may identify potential areas of concern, but they do not provide direct insight into the effectiveness of security controls.
B. Return on security investment: This metric calculates the return on investment (ROI) of security expenditures. While ROI is a useful metric to evaluate the financial performance of security investments, it is not a reliable indicator of security control effectiveness. A positive ROI could indicate that security investments are providing value, but it doesn't necessarily mean that the security controls in place are effective in preventing or mitigating security incidents.
C. Security metrics: Security metrics are the most direct way to measure the effectiveness of security controls. Metrics can include things like the number of security incidents per month, the time it takes to detect and respond to security incidents, and the number of successful phishing attempts. By tracking these metrics over time, organizations can identify trends and make informed decisions about how to improve their security controls.
D. User access rights: User access rights are an important aspect of security controls, but they are just one piece of the puzzle. While controlling user access can help prevent unauthorized access to sensitive data and systems, it does not provide a complete picture of the effectiveness of security controls.
In conclusion, while all of the options listed are important in their own right, security metrics are the most effective way to ensure that security controls are actually working as intended. By regularly reviewing security metrics, organizations can identify areas of weakness and make data-driven decisions about how to improve their security posture.