You work as a machine learning specialist for a sports analytics company.
The Major League Baseball Association has contracted your company to perform real-time analytics on baseball statistics as baseball plays unfold live on national television.
Your first assignment is to predict the outcome of situational set plays (such as stolen bases or pitch results) as they are about to unfold.
Therefore, your model must deliver its predictions in close to real-time. You have decided to use a SageMaker built-in algorithm.
You have looked at classical forecasting methods like autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) and exponential smoothing (ETS) which use one model for each time series in your data.
However, you have many time series over which to train. Based on your performance requirements and your training requirements, which SageMaker built-in algorithm should you use?
Click on the arrows to vote for the correct answer
A. B. C. D. E. F.Answer: E.
Option A is incorrect.
From the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled Linear Learner Algorithm “Linear models are supervised learning algorithms used for solving either classification or regression problems.” But you are trying to solve one-dimensional time series problem so that you can extrapolate the baseball playtime series into the future.
Option B is incorrect.
From the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled Neural Topic Model (NTM) Algorithm “Amazon SageMaker NTM is an unsupervised learning algorithm used to organize a corpus of documents into topics that contain word groupings based on their statistical distribution.” So this algorithm is used for natural language processing, not time series problems.
Option C is incorrect.
The k-means algorithm is a clustering algorithm.
From the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled K-Means Algorithm “K-means is an unsupervised learning algorithm.
It attempts to find discrete groupings within data, where members of a group are as similar as possible to one another and as different as possible from members of other groups.” You are trying to solve one-dimensional time series problems to extrapolate playtime series into the future, not a data clustering problem.
Option D is incorrect.
From the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled Random Cut Forest (RCF) Algorithm “Amazon SageMaker Random Cut Forest (RCF) is an unsupervised algorithm for detecting anomalous data points within a data set.” But you are trying to solve a one-dimensional time series problem to extrapolate baseball playtime series into the future.
Option E is correct.
From the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled DeepAR Forecasting Algorithm “..
you have many similar time series across a set of cross-sectional units.
For example, you might have time series groupings for demand for different products, server loads, and requests for webpages.
For this type of application, you can benefit from training a single model jointly over all of the time series.
DeepAR takes this approach.
When your dataset contains hundreds of related time series, DeepAR outperforms the standard ARIMA and ETS methods.
You can also use the trained model to generate forecasts for new time series that are similar to the ones it has been trained on.”Also, from the same developer guide, “The training input for the DeepAR algorithm is one or, preferably, more target time series that the same process or similar processes have generated.
Based on this input dataset, the algorithm trains a model that learns an approximation of this process/processes and uses it to predict how the target time series evolves.” So the DeepAR algorithm is used for one-dimensional time series problems for complex analysis like baseball play prediction.
Option F is incorrect.
The XGBoost algorithm is a gradient boosting algorithm.
From the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled XGBoost Algorithm, “gradient boosting is a supervised learning algorithm that attempts to accurately predict a target variable by combining an ensemble of estimates from a set of simpler, weaker models.” You are not trying to predict a target value; you are trying to solve a one-dimensional time series problem.
Reference:
Please see the Amazon SageMaker developer guide titled Use Amazon SageMaker Built-in Algorithms, the AWS Machine Learning Blog titled Now Available in Amazon SageMaker: DeepAR algorithm for more accurate time series forecasting, and the AWS StatCast AI page titled See how AI on AWS gives baseball fans new insights into the game.
Based on the given scenario, the machine learning specialist needs to predict the outcome of situational set plays in real-time as they happen in Major League Baseball games. The specialist needs to choose a SageMaker built-in algorithm that can handle many time series, deliver near real-time predictions, and meet the performance requirements.
Out of the given options, the most suitable algorithm for this task is the DeepAR forecasting algorithm (Option E).
The DeepAR algorithm is a recurrent neural network (RNN) that is designed to handle time series data. It can learn from multiple related time series and make predictions for each of them individually. It is particularly suited for scenarios where historical data is available, and forecasting is required.
The DeepAR algorithm can deliver near real-time predictions since it is optimized to handle streaming data and make predictions at high frequency. It uses mini-batch training, which enables the algorithm to update its parameters quickly based on new data.
Furthermore, the DeepAR algorithm is well suited for this task because it can handle multiple time series simultaneously, unlike classical forecasting methods like ARIMA and ETS, which use one model for each time series. This is advantageous because there are likely many situational set plays that need to be predicted in a single game.
Linear Learner (Option A) and XGBoost (Option F) are both supervised learning algorithms that can handle large datasets, but they are not specifically designed for time series data. K-Means (Option C) is an unsupervised learning algorithm used for clustering data, and Neural Topic Model (Option B) is used for text analysis. Random Cut Forest (Option D) is an unsupervised learning algorithm that can be used for anomaly detection in time series data but is not suitable for forecasting.
In conclusion, the most suitable SageMaker built-in algorithm for this scenario is DeepAR forecasting (Option E) because it is optimized for time series forecasting, can handle multiple time series simultaneously, and can deliver near real-time predictions.